A common question that many homeowners planning bathroom remodels ask their contractors is whether their old bathtub can be refinished or if replacement is the only option.
Replacing a bathtub can add some expense to bathroom renovations, so it is understandable that people might want to save money if they can.
Bathtub refinishing can be an option in some situations, but it is not the best choice in others.
To Replace or Refinish – That Is The Question!
So, which option is better for bathroom remodeling?
The answer to these three simple questions should provide all the answers necessary for homeowners trying to achieve the best bathroom remodels in the most cost-effective ways.
- Style and Type - Whether the bathtub is a set-in tub or a standalone tub, does it match the style and type that is preferred for the bathroom renovation? If so, then refinishing could work over replacing. If not, would it actually make sense to forego preference and re-design the bathroom remodel to keep the same old thing? The answer to this question is definitely one of wants versus needs, but it might matter considerably to some.
- Condition - Bathtub refinishing can be a solution for tubs that are scuffed, scratched, and stained, but if they are in worse condition than that with cracks, dings, and enamel chipped to the metal, refinishing probably will not be enough. The whole point of spending money on bathroom remodeling is to get a fresh, new look with components that either are or look brand new. If professional refinishing will not be able to provide that, replacing the tub is the better option to ensure the homeowner ends up completely happy with their investment. Otherwise, that refinished tub will be very obvious when surrounded by brand-new everything else.
- Tile or Surround - Is the tile or surround in good condition or are there plans to replace them? Refinishing is best when there is no plan to replace the tile or surround. Bathroom remodels that include new tile and surrounds are halfway there already and this is the best time to just go ahead and replace with a new bathtub, too.
Now You Can Make The Right Decision
Although there are times when a professionally refinished bathtub is an appropriate option for inexpensive bathroom remodeling, those spending the money on an actual bathroom remodel are recommended to save a little longer if necessary, then just replace the tub, too.
Unless the existing damage is minor and can be easily covered up, tub refinishing leaves most people unsatisfied with the results in comparison to all the other new and updated finishes.
An experienced bathroom renovations company can give additional advice upon seeing the bathtub in question to determine whether refinishing is an option and will give good results.